No table of contents available
Do emails exchanged in business transactions have legal value? What should a company do when its counterparty denies the content of emails that were previously agreed upon? If not handled properly, the risk of losing legal rights and facing prolonged disputes is unavoidable.
In modern business operations, email is almost the primary communication tool between companies. From contract negotiations, price confirmations, amendments to terms, to work instructions – all can be recorded via email. However, many businesses find themselves in frustrating situations when a partner suddenly denies the entire email correspondence, especially once a dispute arises.
This raises an important question: Can emails be considered legal evidence, and how can businesses protect themselves? The answer is not simple, but with a correct legal understanding, businesses can proactively manage and control risks.
Many businesses mistakenly believe that only paper contracts with signatures and company seals have legal value. In fact, Vietnamese law recognizes electronic data, including emails, as admissible evidence if they meet statutory requirements.
However, whether an email has evidentiary value depends on many factors: the sender and recipient, the expression of intent, data integrity, and the connection between the email and the actual transaction. This is precisely why many businesses “hold the emails but still lose the case.”
In dispute resolution practice, it is not uncommon for parties to deny emails. Motivations may include avoiding obligations, delaying proceedings, or gaining negotiation leverage. More fundamentally, certain weaknesses can make emails legally vulnerable.
In dispute resolution practice, it is not uncommon for parties to deny emails. Motivations may include avoiding obligations, delaying proceedings, or gaining negotiation leverage. More fundamentally, certain weaknesses can make emails legally vulnerable.
Many emails are merely informational exchanges, preliminary discussions, or use vague wording such as “tentative,” “for reference,” or “to be discussed further.” In such cases, the counterparty may argue that no final agreement was reached.
Emails sent by sales staff, assistants, or technical personnel who lack authority to bind the company are a common loophole that weakens the legal value of email correspondence.
Once a dispute arises, the most important thing is not to act emotionally, but to approach the issue from a legal and strategic perspective.
Businesses should first review the entire chain of emails related to the transaction. A single email is often weak evidence, but a consistent and logical email chain reflecting the negotiation and agreement process carries much stronger evidentiary value.
Emails should also be combined with other evidence such as quotations, contract appendices, invoices, meeting minutes, confirmation messages, or actual performance by the parties. When all documents “tell the same story,” the chance of protecting legal rights increases significantly.
Instead of waiting until disputes arise, businesses should establish legal procedures from the outset. Important emails should clearly state their confirmatory nature, binding terms, and the identity of authorized representatives. In many cases, a single properly drafted confirmation line can make a critical difference in a dispute.
This is why more and more businesses choose ongoing legal advisory services to manage risks during transactions, rather than “firefighting” afterward.
Once a partner formally denies email correspondence, self-negotiation often becomes ineffective. Lawyers can then assess the entire case, identify strengths and weaknesses, and develop an appropriate strategy—from negotiation and mediation to litigation if necessary.
At DEDICA Law Firm, corporate lawyers regularly handle disputes arising from emails, electronic agreements, and poorly drafted contracts. Practical experience shows that many cases initially considered “hopeless” can still be turned around with the right legal approach.
If your partner is denying previously exchanged emails, do not rush to conclude that you have “lost.” Every case has a solution when properly analyzed and handled.
Contact DEDICA Law to receive a tailored legal strategy that protects your rights and minimizes dispute risks.
📞 Hotline: (+84) 39 969 0012 (WhatsApp, WeChat & Zalo available)
🕒 Working hours: Monday – Friday (8:30 – 18:00)
Contact us today for a free initial consultation with our professional lawyers.
Select a platform to view details
