Resolving Child Custody Disputes in Divorce Cases Involving Foreign Elements in Vietnam
When one spouse is a foreign national or the child holds foreign citizenship, divorce proceedings—especially those involving child custody disputes with foreign elements—become more complex than domestic cases. This article provides insights into the legal framework, dispute resolution process in Vietnam, and practical notes to protect the best interests of the child.
1. Legal Basis and Scope of Application
1.1 Relevant Laws and New Guidelines
The 2014 Law on Marriage and Family (Articles 81 and 82) regulates parental rights and obligations to nurture, care for, and educate children after divorce, including visitation and child support responsibilities.
Effective from July 1, 2024, Resolution No. 01/2024/NQ-HDTP of the Judicial Council of the Supreme People's Court provides clearer guidance on applying regulations related to child custody, especially how to assess “the overall interests of the child” when parents cannot reach an agreement.
In cases involving international elements, Vietnamese courts may still handle divorce and custody if jurisdiction can be established under the Civil Procedure Code or Resolution 01/2024, including cases where the respondent resides abroad and cannot provide a clear address.
1.2 What Qualifies as a “Foreign Element”?
A divorce case is considered to involve foreign elements when at least one of the following occurs:
One party is a foreigner or holds foreign citizenship.
The child holds foreign nationality or is being raised overseas.
The divorce was initiated abroad and later brought to Vietnam for recognition.
A Vietnamese citizen living abroad requests to file for divorce in Vietnam.
When any of these apply, it’s essential to carefully identify the appropriate court, applicable law, and proper methods of notifying a foreign-based respondent.
2. Jurisdiction and Procedures for Vietnamese Courts in Custody Disputes
2.1 Determining Jurisdiction
In many cases, Vietnamese courts have jurisdiction to resolve divorce cases involving foreign elements, especially when the child is currently residing in Vietnam.
If the respondent is a foreigner or a Vietnamese citizen residing abroad without a known address, the court may still proceed with a trial in absentia after fulfilling notice and public posting requirements as guided by Resolution 01/2024.
When the divorce was adjudicated abroad but needs recognition in Vietnam (e.g., to enforce custody or support obligations), a request for recognition of the foreign judgment must be filed following Vietnamese procedural rules.
2.2 Custody Dispute Resolution Process
Mutual Agreement
If both parties agree on custody, support obligations, and visitation that align with the child’s best interests, the court will recognize the agreement as long as it doesn’t violate laws or harm the child.
Court Filing
If no agreement is reached, either party can file a lawsuit seeking custody rights.
The court will assess the child’s best interests in a holistic manner, guided by Resolution 01/2024.
For children aged 7 or older, the court must consider the child’s wishes, although it is not bound by them if contrary to the child's best interests.
For children under 36 months, custody is generally granted to the mother, unless she is deemed unfit.
Courts must also consider the child’s mental and emotional stability, aiming to avoid unnecessary disruptions in living conditions.
Enforcement in Vietnam
Once a judgment or decision becomes effective, if the child and the custodial parent are in Vietnam, the enforcement of custody, support, and visitation will follow Vietnam’s civil enforcement law.
If one party resides abroad, international enforcement must follow applicable treaties or mutual recognition mechanisms.
3. Key Factors in Determining Custody in International Divorce Cases
Even with foreign elements, Vietnamese courts base custody decisions on several internal factors, including:
Parental capability: financial stability, occupation, residence, time availability, and capacity to protect and raise the child.
Emotional bonds: the strength of the relationship and prior contact between parent and child.
Child’s preference: applicable if the child is 7 years or older.
Stability of the child’s environment: evaluating the impact of relocation (especially abroad) on education, communication, cultural adaptation, care, and residency status.
Child’s nationality: if the child holds foreign citizenship, the court may consider whether living in the foreign country would be more beneficial—but it is not the sole deciding factor.
Mother’s condition: as per Resolution 01/2024, a mother may be deemed unfit if suffering from serious illness, earning below half of the regional minimum wage, or lacking sufficient time for caregiving.
4. Practical Example and Strategic Solutions
Illustrative Case
Mr. A (a Vietnamese national) marries Ms. B (a foreign national). After several years living in Vietnam, they have a child with dual citizenship. Upon divorce, Ms. B wants to take the child abroad for education, while Mr. A wants the child to remain in Vietnam.
Mr. A files for divorce in a Vietnamese court, citing that the child resides in Vietnam (valid jurisdiction).
The court finds Mr. A’s caregiving conditions to be stable, with ample time and an emotionally secure environment for the child. Ms. B cannot substantiate a better educational environment abroad.
If the child is 7 or older, the court will consult the child’s opinion.
Result: The court awards custody to Mr. A in Vietnam, and Ms. B retains visitation rights and child support responsibilities.
Strategies to Improve Custody Success
Gather documents proving caregiving capability: income, housing, schedules, degrees, and living conditions.
Maintain consistent communication and emotional bonds with the child.
If planning to take the child abroad, provide a detailed, practical plan demonstrating educational and welfare benefits.
Allow the child to express genuine opinions when consulted by the court.
If the respondent is a foreign national, work on cooperation or seek third-party assistance in delivering notices or power of attorney.
5. Conclusion
Child custody disputes in divorce cases involving foreign elements in Vietnam are legally and procedurally complex, requiring knowledge of national and international laws as well as solid evidence of parental capabilities. However, with thorough preparation, clear documentation, and a strategic approach, your child’s interests can be fully protected.
If you’re facing a similar situation or need help drafting petitions, assessing parental fitness, gathering child opinions, or enforcing decisions across borders, don’t hesitate to reach out for detailed legal support tailored to your case.
Contact DEDICA Law Firm for expert legal consultation!
📞 Hotline: (+84) 39 969 0012 (Available on WhatsApp, WeChat, and Zalo)
🏢 Head Office: 144 Vo Van Tan Street, Xuan Hoa Ward, Ho Chi Minh City (144 Vo Van Tan Street, Vo Thi Sau Ward, District 3, Ho Chi Minh City)
🕒 Business Hours: Monday – Friday (8:30 AM – 6:00 PM)
Reach out today for a free initial consultation with our team of professional lawyers!
